In progress and under consideration – Peer Review – Cassidy Rossander

In Progress and Under Consideration is a reflective series prepared for Publishing 201 – the Publication of the Professional Self. This series is in part a fulfillment of a pre-discussed and agreed upon exchange of academic services and goods, and also a personal reflection on where I’m going and whatever it is I’m doing here.

Cassidy Rossander – Oceanside Reads: Fill your shelves – oceansidereads.com

Cassidy has set up a book review site for Young Adult Fiction, framing her site to showcase books with relatable characters in her age group. This focus is an interesting one (I don’t know when’s the last time I read about someone in my age group to be honest).

There’s two odd quirky things in her ‘about’ section. The first being that it’s a category composed of posts. I don’t know if she’s thinking of expanding it with additional ‘about me’ content in the future, but I think it could function as a more permanent page. In one of her process posts she’s noted that most visits hover on the homepage. I agree with her that it works since her homepage is a blog feed that keeps the most recent content at the top. Given that however, I’m thinking it might be useful to make a little snippet of the ‘about’ section available on the front page, perhaps in the right sidebar somewhere. That way, her specific age-group focus is always available, even if you don’t make it into interior pages. The second strange thing is the most recent post in the ‘about’ section, which is ‘A video from me to you.’ It is set as a downloadable ~70 mb file so it’s not the most accessible form. I didn’t realize it was just going to start downloading when I clicked on it. Typically don’t download from sites I don’t know, so I don’t know how effective that would be with first time visitors.

In terms of social media, Cassidy has an oceansidereads Instagram. It’s accessed by a little Instagram icon but that is also odd. It loads from the top left corner every time you open a page and then it swings across diagonally to the lower right corner where it kind of hovers. It tracks with you if you scroll up and down the page. I only saw it in my peripheral vision since I somehow didn’t see it fly across the page the first couple times. it’s small and in a strange place, but it sticks out on the wood background photo so it works for now.

On Instagram she has several posts of different books she’s been reading. Some are alone and others in pairs, she has a brief comment and often directs people to a link in her bio. This is a common approach for Instagram accounts which constantly update the bio to redirect to the current hot thing. Right now the link is to her homepage, and I’m uncertain if this is typical. Her approach to the writing has some variety, sometimes it’s just the name and author, at other times it’s a suggestion to read, and then sometimes it’s just an intriguing statement like “These books go together like peanut butter and jelly.” Visually I think the photography could be tightened up. I’m intrigued by the blanket as the choice of backdrop. I’m thinking some improved lighting (covers sell books!) as well as a more focused visual approach would help. I know some indie magazine shops use their floors and they’re kind of iconic in that way, or perhaps each book could get a different environment that makes sense with the book. Something more along the lines of the first and third photo which look interesting and more atmospheric. Overall I think it’s a solid start, You can tell she’s been reading lots ,so content wise it’s happening, now it’s down to sharing those reviews.

 

Share this Post